Shop the Collection

Sugarcreek Too Inc.

61 pieces available for sale online, many more in-store.

Pretty Hand knotted Large Pearl necklace
Available
Vintage

Pretty Hand knotted Large Pearl necklace

Unbranded
Good
$45

Exude timeless elegance with this exquisite hand-knotted pearl necklace. Each large, lustrous white pearl is meticulously strung to provide a classic silhouette, while the adjustable clasp ensures a perfect fit for any neckline. This sophisticated piece brings a touch of refined vintage glamour to any ensemble.

Curated by
New Olive Leaf Wreath , accents of olive fruit & Twigs
Available
Rustic

New Olive Leaf Wreath , accents of olive fruit & Twigs

New
Good
$19.99

Bring a touch of Mediterranean charm into your home with this lovely olive leaf wreath! Adorned with delicate olive fruit and rustic twigs, this piece is the perfect way to add a fresh, nature-inspired flourish to any door or wall.

Curated by
Williams Sonoma "Little Drummer Boy Design
Available
Vintage

Williams Sonoma "Little Drummer Boy Design

William Sonoma
Good
$24.95

William Sonoma "Pa Rum Pa Pum Pum " Christmas Carol Plate

Curated by
William Sonoma Christmas Carols Plate
Available
Vintage

William Sonoma Christmas Carols Plate

Williams Somona
Good
$24.95

Bring a dash of musical holiday magic to your table with this delightful Williams Sonoma Christmas Carols plate! Featuring an elegant harp and charming festive imagery, this piece is the perfect way to serve up some seasonal cheer during your next holiday gathering.

Curated by
Williams Sonoma Partridge in a Pear Plate
Available
Vintage

Williams Sonoma Partridge in a Pear Plate

Williams Somona
Good
$24.95

Add a touch of holiday magic to your table with this whimsical Williams Sonoma Partridge in a Pear Plate! Featuring the iconic first day of Christmas carol illustration, this charming piece brings festive cheer to any seasonal gathering. It is the perfect delightful accent for serving up sweet treats or holiday joy.

Curated by
Dooney & Bourke Leather Domed Satchel
Available
Vintage

Dooney & Bourke Leather Domed Satchel

Dooney & Bourke
Good
$149

This exquisite Dooney & Bourke Domed Satchel is a testament to timeless American craftsmanship. Rendered in their iconic, textured pebble leather, this piece perfectly balances professional sophistication with daily functionality, highlighted by the signature duck logo and rich, contrasting leather accents.

Curated by
Harley-Davidson Limited Edition Collector Cards with Wooden Box
Available
Vintage

Harley-Davidson Limited Edition Collector Cards with Wooden Box

Harley-Davidson
Good
$34.95

Celebrate the storied history of American motorcycling with this sophisticated Harley-Davidson limited edition collector card set. Housed in a handsome wooden souvenir box accented with intricate metal relief detailing, this collection serves as a perfect tribute for the devoted enthusiast. Each card offers a fascinating glimpse into the technical specifications and heritage of iconic Harley-Davidson models, making it a distinguished addition to any curated collection.

Curated by
Decorative Rooster Plate Vintage
Available
Vintage

Decorative Rooster Plate Vintage

Raymond Waites
Good
$24.95

Add a touch of farmhouse charm to your home with this delightful decorative rooster plate by Raymond Waites. Its warm, rustic hues and artistic depiction of a proud rooster make it the perfect accent piece for any kitchen wall or display cabinet. It is a whimsical find that brings a bit of country sunshine and personality to your decor collection!

Curated by
Decorative Bulbous Vase
Available
Vintage

Decorative Bulbous Vase

Vintage
Good
$45

This exquisite Decorative Bulbous Vase showcases a sophisticated geometric pattern in a timeless blue and white palette. Its sweeping, rounded silhouette and intricate surface detailing evoke a classic aesthetic that seamlessly elevates any curated shelf or mantel. A stunning example of decorative artistry, this piece brings a refined sense of balance and texture to your collection.

Curated by
Shawnee Duck Vintage Planter
Available
Vintage

Shawnee Duck Vintage Planter

Shawnee
Good
$14.95

Add a touch of whimsical charm to your home with this delightful Shawnee Duck planter! With its sweet bonnet and dainty blue bow, this cheerful little companion is ready to hold your favorite succulent or springtime blooms. It is an absolute treasure for any collector looking to brighten their space with a dash of classic, playful nostalgia.

Curated by
Cracker Barrel Gingerbread Cookie Jar
Available
Vintage

Cracker Barrel Gingerbread Cookie Jar

Cracker Barrel
Good
$25.95

Sweeten up your kitchen decor with this delightful Cracker Barrel gingerbread cookie jar! With a festive scarf and a charming candy cane in hand, this cheerful little fellow is ready to bring a touch of holiday magic to your countertop year-round.

Curated by
Elephant Crossbody Embriodered Bad
Available
Vintage

Elephant Crossbody Embriodered Bad

Unbranded
Good
$21.95

Add a touch of whimsy to your wardrobe with this enchanting elephant crossbody bag! Intricately embroidered and adorned with shimmering sequins, this playful accessory is the perfect companion for your next big adventure. You'll love the colorful fringe detail that brings a festive spirit to every step you take.

Curated by
Goebel Cherub Gathering Harvest
Available
Vintage

Goebel Cherub Gathering Harvest

Goebel
Good
$21.95

Bring a touch of whimsical harvest charm to your home with this delightful Goebel cherub figurine. This sweet little harvest-gatherer is beautifully crafted, capturing a moment of pure joy that will make a lovely addition to any shelf or mantel.

Curated by
Antique Silver Plate Tea Ball Spoon
Available
10% Off
Antique

Antique Silver Plate Tea Ball Spoon

Unbranded
Good
$19.76
$21.95

Brew up a little vintage magic with this lovely antique silver plate tea ball spoon! Featuring an ingenious hinged perforated infuser bowl and an elegant patterned handle, it brings old-world charm straight to your afternoon tea ritual. A delightful treasure that turns every cup of loose-leaf into a celebration of timeless style.

Curated by
Antique Glass & Gold Vase
Available
10% Off
Antique

Antique Glass & Gold Vase

Unbranded
Good
$116.1
$129

This exquisite antique glass vase showcases brilliant clarity through its heavy, prism-cut body, beautifully framed by an ornate gold-toned metal mounting. The architectural stepped pedestal and scrolling acanthus-style handles evoke the grandeur of the Victorian era, offering a sophisticated silhouette for a refined interior. A masterful blend of material and form, this piece captures the light to create a radiant centerpiece for any discerning collector's display.

Curated by
Moonstone Sterling Silver dangle earrings
Available
10% Off
Vintage

Moonstone Sterling Silver dangle earrings

Unbranded
Good
$80.1
$89

These ethereal dangle earrings feature luminous teardrop-shaped moonstones cradled within ornate sterling silver rope-work borders. The moonstones exhibit a mesmerizing adularescence, catching the light with a soft, glowy depth that has long been prized in fine artisan jewelry. Suspended from elegant silver wires, these timeless pieces offer a touch of celestial beauty and classic sophistication to any ensemble.

Curated by
Vintage Art Deco-style earrings
Available
10% Off
Art Deco

Vintage Art Deco-style earrings

Unbranded
Good
$31.5
$35

Embrace the bold geometric aesthetics of the machine age with these striking Art Deco-style earrings. Featuring a sleek, architectural silhouette with tiered triangular motifs, this vintage pair captures the essence of 1920s glamour and modernism. The polished metallic finish ensures they serve as a sophisticated statement piece, perfect for adding a touch of vintage elegance to a contemporary ensemble.

Curated by
Hamsa Hand Dangling earrings vintage
Available
10% Off
Vintage

Hamsa Hand Dangling earrings vintage

Unbranded
Good
$80.1
$89

These vintage dangling earrings feature the Hamsa Hand, a revered symbol across cultures for protection and strength. The intricate openwork filigree on each hand provides a captivating visual texture, catching the light elegantly as they move. Suspended from sleek silver-toned hoops, these pieces combine spiritual significance with a classic design aesthetic suitable for any discerning collector.

Curated by
Sterling Silver Turquoise florla cluster ring
Available
10% Off
Vintage

Sterling Silver Turquoise florla cluster ring

Unbranded
Good
$89.1
$99

This exquisite sterling silver ring features a dynamic floral cluster design, showcasing vibrant turquoise cabochons set within delicate, blooming silver petals. The organic, vine-like structure wraps elegantly around the finger, embodying the timeless allure of Southwestern-inspired craftsmanship. A perfect statement piece for the collector of fine silver jewelry, it captures the natural beauty and spirit of the desert landscape.

Curated by
vintage antique style ornate bracelet
Available
10% Off
Vintage

vintage antique style ornate bracelet

Vintage
Good
$71.1
$79

This exquisite silver-tone cuff bracelet features an ornate floral centerpiece that captures the timeless elegance of vintage-inspired design. Each petal is meticulously detailed and encrusted with shimmering clear crystals, while a single canary yellow stone adds a sophisticated pop of color to the composition. The wide, textured band provides a bold presence on the wrist, making it a statement piece for any discerning collector of classic jewelry.

Curated by
Vintage Sterling Silver Beaded two strand bracelet
Available
10% Off
Vintage

Vintage Sterling Silver Beaded two strand bracelet

Vintage
Good
$80.1
$89

Exuding a classic mid-century charm, this vintage sterling silver bracelet features a refined two-strand silhouette composed of polished, spherical beads. The lustrous finish of the silver creates a timeless appeal, making it a versatile staple for the discerning collector's jewelry box. A sturdy lobster clasp ensures secure wear, completing a piece that balances elegant simplicity with artisanal quality.

Curated by
Freshwater vintage baroque  pearl long neklace
Available
10% Off
Vintage

Freshwater vintage baroque pearl long neklace

Vintage
Good
$80.1
$89

This exquisite vintage long-strand necklace showcases the organic allure of genuine freshwater baroque pearls, known for their unique, non-spherical shapes and luminous luster. Each pearl radiates a soft, creamy iridescence, making this a versatile piece that effortlessly bridges the gap between classic elegance and modern bohemian style. Its generous length allows for sophisticated styling options, whether draped long for a dramatic silhouette or layered for a more intricate, textured appearance.

Curated by
Sterling Dolphin Figurine Pendant
Available
10% Off
Vintage

Sterling Dolphin Figurine Pendant

Vintage
Good
$58.5
$65

A graceful expression of marine-inspired elegance, this sleek sterling silver pendant captures the fluid motion of a dolphin mid-leap. The polished finish highlights the minimalist lines and rhythmic curve of the figure, showcasing a timeless design that transitions effortlessly from day to evening wear. Perfectly suited for collectors of fine nautical jewelry, this vintage piece embodies a spirited charm and sophisticated craftsmanship.

Curated by
Brighton Filigree Medallion Necklace with lon chain
Available
10% Off
Vintage

Brighton Filigree Medallion Necklace with lon chain

Brighton
Good
$53.1
$59

This elegant Brighton necklace features a masterfully crafted filigree medallion, showcasing the brand's signature devotion to intricate, scrolled metalwork. The circular pendant is punctuated by shimmering clear crystals that catch the light, creating a sophisticated radial pattern that exudes timeless charm. Suspended from a long, versatile link chain and finished with the iconic Brighton heart charm, this piece offers a refined aesthetic for the discerning collector.

Curated by